[IconItem] Default onClick Behavior Should NOT be an Open Box

[Ming Zhe Huang]

Please try the attached test case.
This also comes from a customer case. Currently we have 4 clicking behaviors of IconItem?:

• define innerHTML: show it in an open box.
• 'moveTo': transit to a view
• 'href': load the remote HTML
• 'url': pull in the remote HTML

But if we do NONE of above for the IconItem?, it will still open a box after clicking. I think this is not a correct behavior:

1. we already have an explicit way of an open box.
2. In many cases, what people want is none of the 4 behaviors provided. Instead, they want a custom behavior like popping up a dialog or showing some text after clicking. The formal way is to define nothing but to register a click handler. However, the default behavior breaks them all.

I suggest we should do nothing if there's no innerHTML, 'moveTo', 'href' or 'url'.

[Ming Zhe Huang]

test case

[Atsushi Ono]

We have moveTo="#" option for this purpose. Nothing happens (except icon highlight) when you click the IconItem with moveTo="#" parameter, which is in common with ListItem.

[Ming Zhe Huang]

Replying to onoat:

We have moveTo="#" option for this purpose. Nothing happens (except icon highlight) when you click the IconItem with moveTo="#" parameter, which is in common with ListItem.

Thanks. Are you going to further change the default behavior? If not, then please feel free to close it.